
[Licensed agent name, NPN #] ยท Last reviewed [date]
Short answer: Many coastal carriers will not write a new policy on an older roof, or they will pay only its depreciated value (actual cash value) after a claim. Common cut-offs are around 15 to 20 years for asphalt shingles and longer for metal and tile. A newer or FORTIFIED roof opens up more carriers, lowers premiums and can earn grants in North Carolina.
The roof is the first part of the house wind and hail reach, and roof damage drives storm claims. IBHS research shows that as much as 90% of catastrophe-related insurance claims include roof damage. Older shingles lose their seal and blow off more easily, and once shingles go, water gets in. Carriers respond by pricing, limiting or declining older roofs.
Rules differ by carrier and by state, which is why shopping several carriers matters most for older roofs. A roof one carrier declines may be acceptable to another, especially with an inspection showing good condition.
Expect questions about the roof material, the year it was installed, whether it was fully replaced or patched, and whether it was permitted. Some carriers ask for photos or an inspection. The North Carolina Insurance Underwriting Association (the Beach Plan, also called the Coastal Property Insurance Pool) has required roof age and roof type for new homeowners and wind applications since October 10, 2025. Keep the permit and final invoice from your last roof replacement where you can find them.
Many policies now settle roofs at ACV once they pass a certain age, through an endorsement often called a roof surfacing payment schedule or an ACV roof endorsement. Check your declarations page and endorsements for one.
Worked example (illustrative): a hurricane destroys a 17-year-old asphalt roof with an expected life of 25 years. Replacement costs $20,000. The home has $400,000 of dwelling coverage and a 2% named-storm deductible ($8,000).
Depreciation schedules vary by carrier, but the pattern holds: an older roof on an ACV settlement plus a percentage storm deductible can leave the whole replacement to you.
Florida does. Under Florida law, insurers cannot refuse to write or renew a home only because its roof is less than 15 years old. For older roofs, if an inspection shows at least five years of useful life left, the insurer cannot refuse coverage based on age alone. North Carolina has no similar statute, so carrier guidelines decide. [IZC to confirm for other states where IZC writes.]
Starting January 1, 2027, IBHS will not re-designate a FORTIFIED asphalt shingle roof older than 15 years. A FORTIFIED designation lasts five years, so an asphalt FORTIFIED roof installed today can keep its designation through about three renewals. After that, keeping the FORTIFIED credit will likely mean a new roof. The rule covers re-designation only and does not set a service life for shingles.
Rarely for insurance alone, but often once everything is counted. A new roof can move you from a state plan to a private carrier, switch roof coverage from ACV back to replacement cost, add a FORTIFIED credit and, in North Carolina, come with a grant for Beach Plan policyholders. If your roof is already near the end of its life, timing the replacement around your renewal can make those savings start sooner.
Can I insure a 20-year-old roof? Often yes, but with fewer carriers, possibly ACV coverage on the roof and a higher premium. An independent agent can check which carriers still accept it.
Does a roof certification help? Yes. A roofer's certification of remaining life is accepted by some carriers in place of age alone.
Will a new roof lower my premium right away? Usually at your next renewal, or mid-term if your carrier allows. Send the invoice and permit to your agent.
Does a roof repair reset the roof's age? Usually not. Carriers generally go by the date of the last full replacement, though documented repairs can help with underwriting.
How do I find out if my policy has an ACV roof endorsement? Look at the list of endorsements on your declarations page for a roof surfacing payment schedule or an actual cash value roof endorsement, or ask your agent.
Older roof? Tell us its age and type and we will find carriers that still accept it. Start a quote or call (404) 795-4807.
Our licensed specialist will search for the best insurance quotes and will email you when ready.